I just don’t get it, I am afraid.
Whilst I appreciate the skill, the team-work and the sheer pressure involved, I find the very idea of competitive gardening a la Chelsea Flower Show totally perplexing.
Fellow writers and garden designers probably despair about my naïvety – but I do acknowledge another view: We should appreciate Chelsea for what it is – the best and the most prestigious garden design arena in the world.
For the designers, a Chelsea medal (preferably gold) is as good as it gets. Long live aspiration and ambition; for the most innovative and inspirational few, the rewards can lead to international respect, megabucks even, and almost chef-y celebrity.
And I also get the idea of charities big (and especially small), using Chelsea to raise their own profiles by sponsoring gardens and, in so-doing, showcasing the work of less well-known designers.
But how is it that big-hitting Chelsea-style competitive design has become so divorced from the day-to-day pleasure of fiddling-around-getting-soil-y gardening.
An ‘ordinary’ garden is a place of creativity and personal achievement, often – but not always – beautiful in the eye of the beholder. But more importantly it is a place just to be in, to potter in, or simply to sit and do nothing in (albeit for two nanoseconds after which you notice something that needs ‘adjusting’).
Is a garden that has nowhere obvious to sit – with walkways that are so narrow, between stylishly clipped, broad and dense hedges that you would have to travel around it on a scooter, and where you can scarcely even reach to touch, smell or tend the pretty pockets of plants between them – really a garden? Not for me it isn’t.
And I don’t think that a garden loomed-over by a vast rusty-looking lump of something that resembles a chunk of space debris (containing a ‘studio’, apparently) cuts the mustard as a place to relax, either.
I should love to have a gander at the clipboards of the RHS judging posse as they stand around stroking their beards wondering which Emperor, this year, is wearing the very best new clothes:
Dominating inanimate but incomprehensible feature… tick.
Arty torrents or mesmerising black water (no blanket weed, not a single stray leaf floating in it)… tick.
Something deeply symbolic made of rough-hewn stone… tick.
Uniformly sized perfect trees planted too close for comfort all in a row… tick.
And (this year) muted fluffy planting, lots of cow-parsley-lookalikes and not a square inch of the essential brown stuff showing anywhere… tick.
Meanwhile, pressing against the ropes, the gardening public ogles, overwhelmed – or in some cases, dare I say it, somewhat under-awed by it all.
Ah, but following months of preparation and a frantic week of high-brow discussion, there is a special award to placate the traditionalists and design-numpties like me: The People’s Choice Award, voted for by the gardening public, invariably goes – surprise, surprise – to the garden that looks the most comfortable to be in. Sadly, it doesn’t seem to have anything like the cachet of the others. After all, what would the gardening public know?
So every year I return home from Chelsea, breathe a sigh of relief, pour myself a glass of Sauvignon, go outside and slump on to a bench to take in the day’s delights and think: My garden – right now.
For me that’s the place to be.
3 thoughts on “Chelsea – digging myself a big hole?”
I do agree. And for all “normal” gardeners the fuss of “I didn’t get gold, but I should have done”, which has erupted this year, is just another layer of esotericism which so often makes these gardens spectacles to puzzle over.
As a new gardener, I have to say I don’t find Chelsea much of an inspiration – it’s so divorced from reality.
I think we could leave space in the world for people who wish to create a garden in the same spirit as they might write a novel, paint a painting or choreograph a dance.
The fact that there are lots of Sunday painters and aspiring dance troupes slogging away in their backyards doesn’t detract from the Tate or Covent Garden. I think both can happily co-exist and no-one will prevent you having a potter.